top of page

Party Menu

Please place all party orders at least 24 hours in advance.



Party Sandwiches

Sold by the tray, by the dozen, and in take-home quarts, pints, and half-pints.




LARGE SANDWICH TRAY

120 pieces. Serves 20-25. Up to 4 types of sandwiches.

$48.99

Choose sandwich types

Pimento Cheese

Chicken Salad

Egg Salad

LARGE SANDWICH TRAY


SMALL SANDWICH TRAY

56 pieces. Serves 10-15. Up to 3 types of sandwiches.

$27.99

Choose sandwich types

Pimento Cheese

Chicken Salad

Egg Salad

SMALL SANDWICH TRAY


BY THE DOZEN

48 Finger Sandwiches per dozen. Each whole sandwich is trimmed and quartered. These come wrapped two whole sandwiches per pack. Packaged in a box.

$22.99




Party Trays

like fruit and veggie trays, and meat, cheese, and relish trays.




VEGETABLE TRAY

Broccoli, Cauliflower, Carrots, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Celery. Includes Ranch Flavored Cream Cheese Dip Large serves 50-60 Small serves 25-30

Large

$48.99


Small

$29.99

VEGETABLE TRAY


CHEESE BALL with CRACKERS

Cheese ball covered in chopped nuts. Served on a tray with crackers. Large- 2.5-3 lbs, serves 30-40 Small- 1.5 lbs, serves 20-25

Large

$49.99


Small

$29.99


Large without crackers

$31.99


Small without crackers

$20.49



RELISH TRAY

Variety of Olives, Pickles, and Pimento Cheese-stuffed celery. Serves 50-60.

$65.99



MEAT & CHEESE TRAY

5 lbs. of deli-sliced Ham, Turkey, and Roast Beef. Sliced American Cheese and Swiss Cheese. Includes a bread tray of white and wheat bread, and mustard, mayonnaise, and pickles. Serves 25-30.

$82.99

MEAT & CHEESE TRAY


HOR d'OEUVRE TRAY

5 lbs. of deli-sliced Ham, Turkey, and Roast Beef. Sliced American Cheese and Swiss Cheese. Includes a bread tray of white and wheat bread, and mustard, mayonnaise, and pickles. Serves 25-30.

$82.99



CHEESE TRAY

Variety of Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Colby Jack, and Swiss cheese cubes serves on a large tray with grapes. Serves 40-50. PARTY TRAYS VEGETABLE TRAY Broccoli, Cauliflower, Carrots, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Celery Includes Ranch Flavored Cream Cheese Dip LARGE: Serves 50-60 $48.99 SMALL: Serves 25-30 $29.99 CHEESE BALL with CRACKERS Cheeseball covered in chopped nuts. Served on a tray with crackers LARGE: 2.5-3 lbs. Serves 30-40 $49.99 without crackers $31.99 SMALL: 1.5 lbs. Serves 20-25 $29.99 without crackers $20.49 RELISH TRAY Variety of Olives, Pickles, and Pimento Cheese-stuffed celery. Serves 50-60. $65.99​ MEAT TRAY 5 lbs. of deli-sliced Ham, Turkey, and Roast Beef. Sliced American Cheese and Swiss Cheese. Includes a bread tray of white and wheat bread, and mustard, mayonnaise, and pickles. Serves 25-30. $82.99 HOR d'OEVRE TRAY Swedish Meatballs, Cocktail Smokies, Petite Quiche, and Egg Rolls. Serves 30-35. $82.99 CHEESE TRAY Variety of Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Colby Jack, and Swiss cheese cubes serves on a large tray with grapes. Serves 40-50.

$82.99



FRUIT TRAY

In-Season fruits: Cantaloupe, Honeydew, Strawberries, Apples, Watermelon, Grapes, Pineapple. Serves 35-40.

$76.99

FRUIT TRAY



Party Foods

Sold by the dozen unless noted otherwise.




DEVILED EGGS

24 halves

$22.99

DEVILED EGGS


CHICKEN WINGS

Fried or Hot

How would you like them?

Fried

Hot



CHICKEN FINGERS

Served with honey mustard.

$17.99



CHICKEN NUGGETS

with sauce

$6.99



STEAK NUGGETS

with sauce

$6.99



SWEDISH MEATBALLS

$10.99



MARINATED COCKTAIL SMOKIES

$5.99



CHEESE STRAWS

$9.99

CHEESE STRAWS


BISCUITS with HAM or SAUSAGE

$17.99



POTATO CHIPS

per pound

$5.99



MIXED NUTS

per pound

$10.99



CAKE SQUARES

We do not offer custom decorating, only a colored flower.

$24.99

CAKE SQUARES


WATERMELON BOAT

Cut seasonal fruit served in a hollowed out Watermelon. Serves 40-50.

$89.99



BROWNIES

$13.99

BROWNIES


COOKIES

Chocolate chip or Oatmeal.

$9.99

Chocolate Chip or Oatmeal

Chocolate Chip

Oatmeal

COOKIES


FRUIT BOWL

In-season fruits: Cantaloupe, Honey Dew, Strawberries, Apples, Watermelon, Grapes, Pineapple. Serves 20.

$36.99




Dips

Sold by the pint.




ONION, VEGETABLE, FRUIT, or CHEESE DIPS

$10.99

Choose your dip

Onion

Vegetable

Fruit



CRAB, SHRIMP, DATE-NUT, or SPINACH DIPS

$12.99

Choose your dip

Crab

Shrimp

Date-Nut




Beverages

Party-size beverages. Sold by the gallon.




FRUIT PUNCH

Cherry, Orange, Lime, Pineapple, Strawberry, Orange-Pineapple. 30 Servings per gallon.

$9.99

Choose your punch

Cherry

Orange

Lime



TEA or LEMONADE

$6.49

Tea or Lemonade

Tea

Lemonade




Tailgate Special




TAILGATE SPECIAL

Includes: 18 Chicken Fingers or Wings 1 Dozen Sandwiches, up to 2 kinds One Pint of Cole Slaw or Potato Salad

$44.99

Choose your Chicken

18 Chicken Fingers

18 Chicken Wings


CONTACT US

LET'S DO THIS THE OLD-FASHIONED WAY.

Give us a call or stop by.

(803) 781-4002

7235 St. Andrews Rd

Columbia, SC 29212

Monday - Saturday   7 am -3 pm

Sunday Closed

© 2026 Mathias Sandwich Shop | All Rights Reserved | Site by Niche & Notable

  • Facebook
bottom of page